These are my favorite dishes I’ve eaten in New York broken down by category. I can’t claim to have eaten at even a large percentage of places that serve some of these, but this list represents the best I’ve had. If you have a tip for another place I should try, please leave it in the comments and rate it on DishEnvy!
Pizza
1. Regular Pie at Di Fara
2. Grimaldi’s
3. John’s
Dark Horse: Dean’s
Burger
1. Bacon Cheeseburger @ Little Owl
2. City Hall
3. Better Being Underground
4. Corner Bistro
Dark Horse: M&M Burger @ Rare
Chicken Parm: Faicco’s
Italian Sub: Faicco’s
Lobster Roll
1. Luke’s
2. Lobster Place
Taco
1. Carnitas @ Cascabel Taqueria
2. Carne Asada @ Empellon
3. Fish Taco @ Pinche Taqueria
Doughnut: Banana Glazed Donut @ Donut Plant
Guacamole
1. Fonda
2. Rosa Mexicano
3. Dos Caminos
Chicken Tikka Masala
1. Tamarind
2. Taj Tribeca
Sandwich: Spicy Pork w/ Spicy Meat Sauce @ Meatball Shop
Hot Dog: Cheddar Bratwurst @ Bark
Tuna Melt
1. Eisenburg’s
2. Murray’s Cheese
Hummus: Hummus Place
Kati Roll: Chicken Tikka Roll @ Kati Roll Co.
